• Welcome to the new COTI server. We've moved the Citizens to a new server. Please let us know in the COTI Website issue forum if you find any problems.
  • We, the systems administration staff, apologize for this unexpected outage of the boards. We have resolved the root cause of the problem and there should be no further disruptions.

Need Help from fellow Grognards

Does anyone know where I can find a detailed order of battle from the 5th frontier war?

What admirals commanded what fleets, what squadrons were assigned to what fleets, etc.?
 
Does anyone know where I can find a detailed order of battle from the 5th frontier war?

What admirals commanded what fleets, what squadrons were assigned to what fleets, etc.?
 
I don't have it here to verify, and I don't think it ever named admirals, but I seem to remember The Spinward Marches campaign having a breakdown of 5th Frontier War naval forces of some sort.
 
I don't have it here to verify, and I don't think it ever named admirals, but I seem to remember The Spinward Marches campaign having a breakdown of 5th Frontier War naval forces of some sort.
 
Hans Ranke-Madsen does a LOT of great work with the Spinward Marches. If he sees this thread he may be able to point you to a source.

There was a boxed 5th Frontier War board game, I don't own it so I don't know if the information could be found there.

Mike
 
Hans Ranke-Madsen does a LOT of great work with the Spinward Marches. If he sees this thread he may be able to point you to a source.

There was a boxed 5th Frontier War board game, I don't own it so I don't know if the information could be found there.

Mike
 
Originally posted by leadhead:
Does anyone know where I can find a detailed order of battle from the 5th frontier war?

What admirals commanded what fleets, what squadrons were assigned to what fleets, etc.?
I'm sure that there are lists of the squadrons and the admirals that have counters representing them in FFW floating around.

One problem is that some people (me among them) think that the list is inadequate, because FFW was produced at a time when the population modifier hadn't been introduced. Thus the forces in FFW is based on the assumption that all worlds has (effectively) a PM of 1. Once the PMs are taken into account, you have five times as many taxpayers which (IMO) implies higher budgets which implies more ships and squadrons (Note: Not necessarily five times more).

Another problem is that the list shows admirals and squadrons that MIGHT have been sent to reinforce the Marches. This probably means that some of them wasn't actually sent there "for real". For example, there are four or five admirals in the countermix that are senior to Sector Admiral Santanocheev. This probably represents many or all the sector admirals in Deneb and Corridor. In "reality" one or two of them went to the Marches and the others stayed in Deneb and Corridor and ran things there. FFW presents the possibility of playing the "What If" scenario that someone else went and someone else stayed. Something similar would apply to the ships.

There are a few ships and squadrons that are mentioned in various canonical sources, but a full list of all of them, no.


Hans
 
Originally posted by leadhead:
Does anyone know where I can find a detailed order of battle from the 5th frontier war?

What admirals commanded what fleets, what squadrons were assigned to what fleets, etc.?
I'm sure that there are lists of the squadrons and the admirals that have counters representing them in FFW floating around.

One problem is that some people (me among them) think that the list is inadequate, because FFW was produced at a time when the population modifier hadn't been introduced. Thus the forces in FFW is based on the assumption that all worlds has (effectively) a PM of 1. Once the PMs are taken into account, you have five times as many taxpayers which (IMO) implies higher budgets which implies more ships and squadrons (Note: Not necessarily five times more).

Another problem is that the list shows admirals and squadrons that MIGHT have been sent to reinforce the Marches. This probably means that some of them wasn't actually sent there "for real". For example, there are four or five admirals in the countermix that are senior to Sector Admiral Santanocheev. This probably represents many or all the sector admirals in Deneb and Corridor. In "reality" one or two of them went to the Marches and the others stayed in Deneb and Corridor and ran things there. FFW presents the possibility of playing the "What If" scenario that someone else went and someone else stayed. Something similar would apply to the ships.

There are a few ships and squadrons that are mentioned in various canonical sources, but a full list of all of them, no.


Hans
 
Back
Top