Crimson Cat
SOC-9
As an old timer when it comes to Traveller this discussion about removing or ignoring canon is intersesting and disturbing at the same time.
I only ever played CT and never got into the newer editions. If it wasn't for the reprints I probably not be here on the forum. I am thinking of picking up the new T20 stuff but if it wasn't for the history and background of the Traveller setting there is no way I would be buying it or concider buying it. Also if it was not for the reprints I tend to doubt T20 would have gotten off the ground as well as it did.
Now I understand newer players might not understand this but if you remove the "canon" and only leave a d20 system in space, I have other games I would play instead.
Yes you can do whatever you want with your setting but much of the core base which has kept Traveller going over the years would leave. By alienating the fanbase that kept it going would cause some to really complain and one complainer crowds out many voices of praise.
You can call it legacy or canon in many ways and it makes no difference. You will still have those who will say how dare you change the legacy and other who want it changed.
The only problem is if you purge, you better gauge correctly how many players you can afford to lose, for it will happen. With the amount of d20 stuff being produced I think T20 would be hard pressed stay going under that type of bad press. This is not saying that the game is not well done but I have seen plenty of great games go away due to hurt feelings and such.
With that said I have no problem with correcting canon or making adjustments that maybe needed but one needs to be sensitive to what drive your market.
I only ever played CT and never got into the newer editions. If it wasn't for the reprints I probably not be here on the forum. I am thinking of picking up the new T20 stuff but if it wasn't for the history and background of the Traveller setting there is no way I would be buying it or concider buying it. Also if it was not for the reprints I tend to doubt T20 would have gotten off the ground as well as it did.
Now I understand newer players might not understand this but if you remove the "canon" and only leave a d20 system in space, I have other games I would play instead.
Yes you can do whatever you want with your setting but much of the core base which has kept Traveller going over the years would leave. By alienating the fanbase that kept it going would cause some to really complain and one complainer crowds out many voices of praise.
You can call it legacy or canon in many ways and it makes no difference. You will still have those who will say how dare you change the legacy and other who want it changed.
The only problem is if you purge, you better gauge correctly how many players you can afford to lose, for it will happen. With the amount of d20 stuff being produced I think T20 would be hard pressed stay going under that type of bad press. This is not saying that the game is not well done but I have seen plenty of great games go away due to hurt feelings and such.
With that said I have no problem with correcting canon or making adjustments that maybe needed but one needs to be sensitive to what drive your market.