Originally posted by Anthony:
Actually, the canon is what Marc Miller says it is, which doesn't include either GT or T20 at the moment; ... This does allow an additional level of canon: there's stuff that's not canon, but won't be contradicted unless necessary. An example of this would be the Genii sector files.
HIWG is not canonical. Neither is CORE.
The canon debate is dumb...I can go over to the U of A and find a hundred people to play D&D, but would be hard pressed to find 4 that play Traveller. The reason has always been because of the 'Canon' thing. I can name several people who were involved in HIWG but dropped out due to attitude from the publishing companies over canon, and whether stuff developed by fans and players was worthy or not. Why else did GDW and other Traveller companies go belly up while other RPGs of worse caliber thrived? Probably because of the attitude that the fans and players were secondary to whatever twisted desires of
publishers ...TNE was the final nail for most - why develop and write for JTAS or other publication when everything was for naught?
I DON'T have a problem with people in power deciding what direction the game takes - What I'm saying is that by deliberately taking the view that some things are not worthy of consideration in the OTU, you are lowering the value of that setting. As far as I'm concerned, Core and HIWG are canon until Miller & Associates decides to publish something that counteracts it. If THEY say it's not,
without publishing , then they doom the game to irrelevance in the greater RPG universe...
Is there any surprise that I have more original D&D stuff in my library than everything published for Traveller across all versions...If every time Traveller gets off and running, and someone comes along and cuts the legs out from under it because of canon issues, it'll never be as big as even the obscure RPGs - And I think Trav is better than those stupid Werewolves, Rifts, or....
The game is made up of publishers AND players, refs, and fans...
-MADDog
-------------------------------------------------
"And from now on, I don't care if my tea leaves spell 'Die Ron, Die' - I'm just chucking them in the bin where they belong."