Andrew Boulton
The Adminator
It took being locked in a room for an hour with a brass band playing carols at me, but I'm *finally* starting to feel Christmassy...
I do not see any problem with wishing a friend of mine a pleasant festive of his religion, even if I believe in completely different things. Religion, after all, is a personal (and by extension, community) thing. Likewise, as a Jew, I do not have any problem with anyone wishing me "happy Hanuka".Originally posted by Aramis:
I have a magnetic placard on my car which reads "Keep Christ in Christmas"...
as far as I'm concerned, all the non-christians SHOULDN'T be saying merry christmas... which means, literally Christ-Mass, the mass of the nativity of christ. A specifically Catholic (and by extension, and by parallelism & scism, sometimes other eucharistic christian) term for a specific form of worship.
Likewise, I've had several Jews get upset that I said "Happy Channukka."
And turkey is a north american bird.Originally posted by veltyen:
Aramis,
By the same token you shouldn't put up a tree (Germanic Pagan), Icons of St Nicolas (Greek Orthodox), or give gifts (Saturnalia in origin). Eating ham would also be off the list, as traditionally this is an offering to Freya.
I've no problem with a generic mid-winter gift-giving festival. I've a problem with turning a major religious holy-day into the most base of commercial concerns.
You might as well ignore the mythic aspects of the festival, the sociological are far more important. The expectations of happy families, the disappointment at the reality, and the need for people to connect and failing are pretty hard on a lot of people. Suicides go up for a reason. They also go up in the southern hemisphere, so it isn't just the winter blues.
Except that it was traditionally placed at 25 Dec, by synodal council ratification of imperial decree, and the calendar change (Pope Gregory's) shifted it, while the Russians, Turks and Greeks didn't shift. Based upon the historical data, the Census was taken in the summer... so its place in the church calendar is linked to the feast of Mithras (Roman Pagan) and the mythic cycle built into the church year. Going into more detail would lose some, confuse others, and not contribute to the ongoing discussion meaningfully, and we're already pushing board boundaries.
BTW Christ-Mass would be January 6.
Rabble rouser.Originally posted by Andrew Boulton:
It took being locked in a room for an hour with a brass band playing carols at me, but I'm *finally* starting to feel Christmassy...
Quite right it does. My daughter went all googly last year, and this year she went bananas. She calls it a "'scuse me tree", capers about it, lays on her side silently contemplating it, and rearranges the low-lying ornaments, sometimes singing while making them "dance".Originally posted by Black Globe Generator:
Seeing the shine in my daughter's eyes as she looks at the lights wrapped around the tree and hanging from the eaves is all it takes for me.![]()