My deck plans showed up - nice basic set. However - there is no key or descriptions. There are a lot of numbered rooms and areas, but nothing to indicate the purpose.
While I have pretty much these plans and descriptions elsewhere, a page or two per deck plan indicating what is what would have been nice so I don't have to look all over to see what room B4 is supposed to be. Fortunately I've the Kinunir adventure (the real deal
) (as well as the Classic CD) so the big ship at least I can map what the rooms do.
And these are basically laid and and displayed much like the plans from 30 years ago. Nicer paper, and there are some T5 touches with consoles and a few other minor updated legend items. So for nostalgia's sake they are really nice. For real use, though, as the scale is too small for 15 mm, so they can't be used as battle maps directly.
A lack of any descriptive text hurts usability quite a bit.
And there are URLs printed on the plans (
www.traveller5.net/DP01.html, for instance) that are invalid. I can hope that the plan is to stick the description there.
So if I had to rate these, I'd give them a 5/5 for classic Traveller appeal, but a 2/5 for real use. Without descriptions, a new to Traveller player would have no idea what anything was.
Edit: must have typed in the URLs incorrectly as they now appear to be working. Alas, still no descriptions of the layout.
To make these really useful (and bump that score to at least a 4), what would have been nice would be to follow one of the Kickstarters: include (or link) a PDF that also has the maps, but scaled to be printed for 25 or 15 mm gaming, along with the descriptions. Maybe even a bit of color (i.e., the PDFs from that give 2 printable maps: black and white similar to these deck plans, but also color with furnishings and stuff).
There are several members here who have already done very similar things, and they looked quite good.
Overall, I am happy with them, but that's mostly from a nostalgia / deck plan addiction point of view...