Originally posted by Liam Devlin:
"Craig the Lizard"( symbol behind him was Brzk's Antares btw) is an errata from MT days.
I'm aware that it was an errata, of course, but I've always liked it as a nickname.
Personally, between Solee/ RC/ UWA/ COE (solomani Rim-David Hale), the Guild is doomed, AlanB. Solee and RC don't want the competition--both have attacked and seized their ships, imprisoned their crews.
Yeah. The problem is that it was set up as an enemy to be defeated.
In fact, if you look at it, it's actually "yet another pocket empire". It's main difference is that it is decentralised, and doesn't have huge fleets and armies. That's not a bad way of doing things in a context where Vampire Fleets can roll up on your doorstep and start laying nukes on you, but it's not good when you are dealing with a more organised opponent.
I don't really think Solee is a major problem for it. The Guild's main sphere of operations seems to be in Diaspora, rather than Old Expanses, so the loss of its operations in the Expanses isn't necessarily fatal.
Similarly, the Terran and Dingir PEs are a long way away, and it should be possible to come to an accomodation with one or the other of them by the time they show up.
The Covenant of Suffren is a worry, but don't seem to be _too_ much of an independent factor.
The outfit in Zarushagar could be an issue too, eventually, but they aren't necessarily going to be hostile.
The real problem is the RC, who are directly advancing into the Guild's heartland.
At some point, of course, the Guild will have to accept that the empire builders are back, but if they do so in a timely manner, there is no reason why they shouldn't be able to go legit. They certainly have enough starports and industry under their influence.
I've always been a bit snaky about how the TNE metaplot told us how things where going to turn out. It made life a bit difficult for those of us who really wanted to build our own little empires.
After all, who would want to go near the RC or the Regency when you could start with your own local TED, a couple of friendly Free Traders and a Patrol Cruiser, and go on to build an interstellar civilisation?
Alan