Someone I knew passed onto me a self-published "Traveller" novel, complete with fan art for the cover. I won't mention said author's name, as he probably visits these boards on occasion, but is was, in a word, awful. What's worse is that the guy poured a lot of effort into it, but it's like he edited the thing himself, which I'm pretty sure isn't too far from the truth. I mean, this guy deserves kudos for the effort. No joke. It takes a lot to write a complete novel. But he really needed some help.Gents,
I voted for "Both", but I'm not exactly holding my breath.
I'm an omnivorous reader, a voluminous reader, and an eclectic reader. I read a lot, I need to read constantly, and when I'm desperate I've been known to read utter crap. Yet despite all that, the TNE novels and T4 novels nearly beat me.
I had to force myself to read them. Force. As in "Attempt and failed multiple times", as in "It took several readings to get through to the end", as in There's time I'll never get back.
Making the matter even worse, I was ashamed that Traveller was associated with these books.
The Dragonlance novels for D&D were bad enough, but the Traveller novels were like becoming personally and painfully aware of a new sexually transmitted disease.
I'll look any new Traveller fiction over, but I'm exactly not expecting much fi anything.
Kafka's idea is probably the best. Come up with a setting bible as was done with Thieves World and let some short writers take a crack at it.
Regards,
Bill
The "Dragonlance" books... oh my. I truly can't imagine what concept was behind these books. And I'm not sure which is worse, the fact that they were published, or the fact that they continue to publish MORE Dragonlance stuff to this very day. Presumably the narrative and syntactic kinks have been ironed out; i.e. good prose with a logic to the story, rather than some half baked setup.
I think some good Traveller fiction might not take the form of novels, but perhaps short stories or, more rather, brief fictional intros to adventures. Just my thoughts.