Making 'makers' a real manufacturing system certainly alters the infrastructure of the setting.
True but, as impressive as makers are, they don't seem to be "Santa Claus" machines like
Trek's replicators either. That is a maker and a bucket of kitty litter won't produce a jump drive simply because you have the right program.
In one of the book's "scrubbings" there's a discussion about the ships involved having enough computer chips on hand and that those chips had been recently both inventoried and tested. That suggests several things about the makers aboard. Either they can't make those chips, can't make them fast enough, can't make them without certain raw materials, or something else. If the makers could produce the chips as required the ships wouldn't be carrying stores of them.
I was struck by the idea of gifting fusion+ and makers to far away planets on the understanding that one day the Imperium would come calling.
That's mentioned a few times, isn't it? Once at Beauniture for certain.
That's also another reason why I believe makers aren't "Santa Claus" machines, that they're constrained in some manner and sometimes constrained by
deliberate design.
Think about it for a moment. It's M:0, Cleon's coup occurred a couple years ago, you're Eneri J. Shugilii of the brand spanking new IISS, you're more than a sector "over the border", and you've just identified a family of oligarchs on Arglebargle-IX capital of the small Bargleargle pocket empire. Your mission is going to give them Fusion+ so they can spark an economic boom, seize/cement their control, and then hand the whole enchilada over to the Imperium in return for a dukedom when the gang from Sylea comes knocking in a generation or three.
Are you going to give a device which can manufacture
every technological marvel available to the Third Imperium from spinal mounts to PGMP-12s to orbital nuclear whoopee cushions?
Or are you going to give them a machine which is constrained by both it's
programming and it's
physical nature to manufacture only what is necessary for a Fusion+ infrastructure plus a carefully selected number of geegaws?
I believe makers are and can be constrained not only by their programming, but also by their physical nature and available inputs. I also believe there are specialized makers which "feed" other makers. Look at the previously mentioned computer chips for example.
Let's say a maker can produce a tablet
without the processor in X minutes. The same maker can build the needed processor in 2X minutes meaning a complete tablet would require 3X minutes to manufacture.
Let's also say a "dedicated", "oriented", "specialized", or whatever maker can make the same processor in X minutes. That maker could then "feed" the first to produce a tablet every X minutes.
Of course I could, as usual, be talking through my hat or out of a certain orifice. It's just that, while I like the idea of makers very much, I don't want them be Santa Claus machines or even replicators.