When did I say I would be dropping a million colonists? That alone is crazy pants numbers based on tonnage available.So,
One of your suggestions is to plant a few thousand, or perhaps a million or so colonists...
....and devote a significant force to "Starting off" by building, then operating a bio-chem genome plant on a scale massive enough to create the ouput needed to plant the fields needed to feed all those people.
Meaning any actual agro-work would have to be delayed until the science staff did their work, and succeeded in bonding Terran plant and mineral-use cellular structures to native plant-life?
So, how long are the planted colonists expected to survive on boxed rations until they can hope to begin working toward sustainability?
Saying "they'll just genegeneer it" does not happen "tomorrow". And colonists have to get up and running fairly quickly, or the colony fails.
Simple answers are like hobbits taking short cuts.
And, sadly, when you finally realize that "simple answer" you throw out will not work, there are populations on a planet that can't support them.
And, you also realize you can't suddenly pull a Dunkirk and re-route merchant and naval ships to help them.
In fact, given the communications shadow, it is likely people will start dying well before initial responses can reach the world. Logistics is a bitch when you realize your "easy answer based on guessed at future tech" fails
I think I first read of Amazon agriculture in a work by either Charles C. Mann, or Jared Diamond. The 'pedia has a decent overview. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pre-Columbian_agriculture_in_the_Amazon_BasinThey could do what the Amazon forest ‘settlers’ did- use charcoal, leftover food and pottery shards to make highly rich soil.
![]()
Terra preta - Wikipedia
en.m.wikipedia.org
So, here's a question, and I don't know.I am also not "Cherry Picking". For example, just because nitrogen exists "somewhere", it doesn't mean you can enhance local soil with it.
from what I've read, "Not in the time implied..."So, here's a question, and I don't know.
There's a plot point in the movie "The Martian" where the astronaut (who happens to be a botanist) grows potatoes using (apparently) little more than Martian soil, "fertilizer", and a chunk of potato.
So, was that complete science fiction, or was the fertilizer enough to make the (I assume) dead soil a suitable enough growing medium?
Nor would I expect to.What you cannot do is grow plants in un-augmented regolith simulant.
So, here's a question, and I don't know.
There's a plot point in the movie "The Martian" where the astronaut (who happens to be a botanist) grows potatoes using (apparently) little more than Martian soil, "fertilizer", and a chunk of potato.
So, was that complete science fiction, or was the fertilizer enough to make the (I assume) dead soil a suitable enough growing medium?
OTOH, if the place is inhabited, it's already got the ability to grow human/Vargr/etc. compatible foodstuffs -- or there couldn't be any inhabitants in the first place.And, that can happen on any planet we want to colonize. Which means it's yet another level of difficulty to providing actual "coffee" parsecs or more away from Terra.(the original point)
Assuming we accept the Beltstrike standard for life support, it’s imminently doable to ship the ‘canned’ stuff in. Artificial vat meat/pap, hydroponics sure.OTOH, if the place is inhabited, it's already got the ability to grow human/Vargr/etc. compatible foodstuffs -- or there couldn't be any inhabitants in the first place.
All it would take is an advance in propulsion and we'd be towing comets to Mars orbit. Maybe even to Venus. After that, we just need to make those Worlds more livable in whatever way.I don't want to spoil it for anyone, maybe we'll get out there and found new worlds, terraform and stuff. Never say never.
I think it was in Schismatrix, they shot comets at Venus, at an angle to induce rotation, pretty cool idea.All it would take is an advance in propulsion and we'd be towing comets to Mars orbit. Maybe even to Venus. After that, we just need to make those Worlds more livable in whatever way.
Perchlorate is toxic, but readily water soluble.Nor would I expect to.
I'm sure everything is context dependent. But I guess its a question of weather the alien soil is augment resistant, or is it just "dead" soil. Naturally incompatible for crop growth.
If the soil is hostile, can it be clean? Can you sterilize it? Or is it simply laced with bad compounds "Oh look, arsenic sure it common here!".
A common method for getting a fertilizer from something common in nature is to use ground / pulverized basalt.So, here's a question, and I don't know.
There's a plot point in the movie "The Martian" where the astronaut (who happens to be a botanist) grows potatoes using (apparently) little more than Martian soil, "fertilizer", and a chunk of potato.
So, was that complete science fiction, or was the fertilizer enough to make the (I assume) dead soil a suitable enough growing medium?